top of page

The Investor Manipulation Game: How Mumbai’s Property Prices Are Inflated

Writer's picture: Sam Dawood Sam Dawood

Mumbai, the bustling financial hub of India, is a city of dreams, thriving with opportunities and a rich cultural tapestry. Yet, its real estate market presents significant challenges, particularly with rapidly rising property prices. These prices often seem disconnected from the financial realities faced by the average buyer. This article explores the notion of demand in Mumbai's property market and whether it is genuinely driven by economic factors or manipulated by investors, builders, and brokers.


This analysis reveals the hidden strategies that artificially inflate property prices, significantly impacting middle-class aspirations for homeownership.


Eye-level view of Mumbai skyline with high-rise buildings
Mumbai's high-rise skyline illustrates the booming real estate market.

Bulk Buying by Investors: How a Handful of Buyers Create Fake Demand


In Mumbai's real estate landscape, one major tactic is bulk buying by wealthy investors. These investors often purchase multiple units in new projects, creating a false sense of high demand. For example, in a recent housing development, an investor acquired 30 out of 100 apartments, leading sellers to falsely believe that the project was in high demand.


This practice skews the market, driving prices up and making it hard for genuine homebuyers to compete. Many of these purchased units remain vacant, contributing to a misleading perception of housing scarcity. Statistics indicate that nearly 20% of homes in Mumbai are unoccupied, highlighting just how significant the issue of speculation is within the housing market.


Deliberate Price Holding: Why Unsold Flats Aren’t Sold at Lower Prices


Another prevalent tactic is deliberate price holding by builders. When flats remain unsold for extended periods, builders often refuse to lower prices. Instead, they hold onto properties, anticipating future price increases. Many developers believe that decreasing prices could devalue their investments.


This results in a downward spiral, where buyers are discouraged from entering a stagnant market. For instance, a prominent builder recently kept prices for a project stagnant for over two years, even though many units were unsold. This approach not only hampers sales but also keeps pricing artificially high, making homes inaccessible to many working-class families.


NRI & Foreign Investment Influence: How International Buyers Push Prices Up


The influx of Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) and foreign investors into Mumbai's property market adds another layer of complexity. These buyers often come with significant disposable incomes and seek luxurious properties for investment or as a symbol of status. The impact is substantial. Reports suggest that NRIs account for nearly 25% of all real estate investments in Mumbai.


This competition pushes local buyers out of the market, leading to escalating prices. As the average home price in Mumbai has risen by approximately 15% year-on-year, many residents now find themselves struggling to identify affordable housing options.


Fake Bookings in Pre-Launch Sales: How Builders Create False Demand


Fake bookings during pre-launch sales is a tactic used by builders to portray high demand for new projects. They advertise pre-launch sales with attractive offers, stirring excitement among potential buyers. However, there are instances where builders inflate booking figures with misleading transactions.


For example, a developer launched a project claiming to have received 200 bookings in a single weekend, while investigations later revealed that only half of those bookings were genuine. This strategy prompts more authentic buyers to act quickly, fearing they might miss out, further driving up property prices.


Media & Broker Misinformation: Why You Always Hear “Prices Will Rise Soon”


Media representation and broker communications play a crucial role in shaping perceptions about the market. Reports and advertisements frequently predict a rise in property prices, instilling urgency among potential buyers. This creates a mentality that investing sooner is wiser, increasing the pressure on buyers.


Consequently, many buyers hastily commit to purchases based on hype rather than genuine market conditions. Brokers often benefit from this surge in demand, leading to inflated commissions. Buyers may find themselves competing in an overheated market, where accurate market information is scarce.


Impact on End-Users: Why Middle-Class Buyers Struggle to Afford Homes


For middle-class buyers, the stakes couldn’t be higher. The cumulative effects of these manipulative tactics render homeownership increasingly unattainable. With the average salary growth in Mumbai lagging behind skyrocketing property prices—growing only about 8% annually—potential homeowners frequently feel they must compromise their dreams.


Homes priced at INR 1 crore (approx. $120,000) or more are common, while many middle-class families earn salaries averaging INR 50,000 (approx. $600) monthly. The disparities force many to consider housing in the outskirts of the city or abandon the dream altogether. The struggle for affordable living spaces reflects a broader narrative of economic inequality and social disillusionment.


The Call for Transparency: A Road to Price Correction


In light of these manipulative practices, there is a growing demand for transparency in Mumbai's real estate market. Governance and policies that enforce accountability among builders, investors, and brokers are essential to fostering a fair market.


Educated buyers, armed with knowledge about market dynamics, can make more informed decisions. The real estate landscape must adapt to create a balanced ecosystem that caters to both investors and end-users. Transparency and fairness must be prioritized to ensure that homeownership remains an achievable goal.


A Shared Path Ahead


Mumbai's real estate market is a complex web influenced by various factors, including tactics that artificially inflate prices. The convergence of bulk buying, price holding, NRI investments, fake bookings, and media hype creates a challenging environment for prospective homeowners.


As awareness grows about these manipulative practices, the call for transparency becomes more urgent. While the road ahead may seem filled with obstacles for potential buyers, an informed approach can empower them to advocate for necessary changes.


The ongoing question is how much longer such market manipulation can persist before authentic demand prevails over inflated values. Only time will tell if a more balanced and equitable housing market can emerge in this vibrant city. Prospective buyers should remain vigilant and informed as they navigate these turbulent waters.

Comments


bottom of page